20y after “All-American Girl”, @ABCNetwork should green-light #FreshOffTheBoat

Photo credit: Jeff Yang
The cast of “Fresh Off The Boat” pilot. Photo credit: Jeff Yang

Middle-class families imagine their stereotypical dinner-time routine as an intimate setting when parents and children might gather over a hearty meal to share funny stories of the day; for mine, as (I suspect) many others, dinner-time conversation is too awkward to be fun. I didn’t care about workplace politics. My parents weren’t concerned about my classroom gossip. Here’s my confession: we really didn’t have much to talk about. Instead, for my family (as I suspect it was for many others), our family-time was watching our favourite family sitcoms over dinner. In some ways, we were inviting the characters of those shows into our lives, to become part of our families, to replace our own (boring) dinner conversation with their (hilarious) adventures.

Since the 1940’s and 1950’s, the American family sitcom has presented an idealized version of the American middle-class family: a nuclear (or oddball) family, facing obstacles with a grin and overcoming them with reaffirmations of love.

Not surprising, therefore, that these images — from Full House and Family Ties and Boy Meets World — are inextricably linked to my generation’s definitions of love, family and Americana. And, from its inception, the sitcom has also been a covertly political tool, pushing our definitions of those very same concepts.

Continue reading “20y after “All-American Girl”, @ABCNetwork should green-light #FreshOffTheBoat”

A mixed day for Asian Americans in sitcoms: Fox puts “Dads”, “Mindy Project” on Hiatus

Seth MacFarlane's 'Dads' just went quietly into the good night.
Seth MacFarlane’s ‘Dads’ just went quietly into the good night.

It’s news that cements the broadcast TV philosophy: ratings, not politics, will make or break a show. Mere months after Seth MacFarlane debuted his live-action sitcom, Dads, to overwhelming outcry from critics and Asian Americans for the racism/sexism/poor quality of its series pilot, Dads has been yanked from Fox’s Tuesday comedy line-up. And it wasn’t the backlash that did Dads in; it was poor ratings. Recent numbers show Dads scored a mere 1.3 on the Neilsen rating scale, which is pretty abysmal for a sitcom with its timeslot.

At a time when there are growing questions within the Asian American blogosphere as to whether or not we’ve become too reactionary to the “small stuff”YouTube videos, for example — it’s important to take heed here. While anti-Asian racism in primetime TV shouldn’t go completely unchallenged, it’s worth remembering that our outcry (or indeed, similar outrage from any marginalized minority) matters less to TV executives than market share. Thus, any political effort launched by our community that could produce as a consequence elevated interest in a show (even in the form of morbid curiousity) must be considered in the context of whether it might help, rather than hinder the media in question.

Continue reading “A mixed day for Asian Americans in sitcoms: Fox puts “Dads”, “Mindy Project” on Hiatus”