Last month, US Customs and Border Protection announced a proposal to institute a “voluntary” social media check of Chinese travelers to the United States. The proposal would add an “optional” question requesting account information for an applicant’s social media accounts to the Electronic Visa Updates System (EVUS), the system that foreign visitors use to manage their visa applications to the United States.
A mandatory social media check policy is already proposed or in place for travelers from several Muslim-predominant countries, and those practices have already been widely criticized as unreasonable and unjust. It is unclear how voluntary the proposed “voluntary” social media check of Chinese travelers will be in practice.
Propublica released findings today suggesting that the Princeton Review — one of the nation’s top standardized test prep services, which offers in-class and one-on-one tutoring options for prospective students — is significantly more likely to charge Asian American students higher prices for the same test prep services.
The disparity comes from a practice employed by many online and offline retailers wherein the price of a good or service is influenced by various factors. Online retailers, in particular, frequently employ an algorithm that factors in buyer geography and other characteristics before generating a quote for a particular item. Although offline markets are required to demonstrate that local differences in prices do not disproportionately impact any particular class of buyer over others, online retailers are not held to the same standard: online retailers are able to collect an unprecedented amount of buyer information before offering a price, and algorithm-based pricing can draw upon a series of seemingly innocuous details about a buyer to create the net effect of setting predatory pricing for some classes of buyers over others.
In a recent White House memo on the effects of “Big Data” and economic activity, advisors warned that algorithm-based pricing could create a novel problem of “digital redlining”, where companies employ unfair economic practices that specifically target certain groups of consumers. That memo urged new regulations to prevent such predatory economic practices, and that would also emphasize online consumer privacy.
Since 2001, Reappropriate has been the web's foremost Asian American activism, identity, feminism, and pop culture blog!