Last month, the Committee Against Anti-Asian Violence (CAAAV) helped to organize a social media-based selfie campaign to create visibility for Asian Americans who support justice for NYPD shooting victim Akai Gurley, who was killed earlier this year by rookie police officer Peter Liang. Liang, who shot Gurley during an unsanctioned vertical patrol and who failed to perform life-saving procedures in the minutes after Gurley was wounded, was indicted by a grand jury on manslaughter charges in Akai Gurley’s death.
While many support Peter Liang’s grand jury indictment as a necessary first step in establishing accountability and oversight for police in the event of a suspicious civilian death, there are those within the Chinese American community who have interpreted Liang’s indictment as evidence of racism, comparing his indictment to the lack of an indictment for the White police officers in the shootings of Michael Brown and Eric Garner.
In the first week of March, an estimated two thousand Chinese American protesters marched in New York City in opposition to Peter Liang’s indictment. In the coming week, organizers hope to take those protests national, with a series of demonstrations protesting Liang’s indictment planned for cities around the country.
Not only is opposition to Peter Liang’s indictment frustratingly illogical, but these protests threaten to dominate coverage of Asian American involvement with what has become labelled America’s new Racial Justice Movement. Already, mainstream media outlets have generalized these protests as representative of all Asian Americans, erasing the sharp political divide within the Asian American community on this topic, and more specifically the countless Asian Americans who strongly support Peter Liang’s indictment and broader mechanisms of police accountability, and who stand in solidarity with the #BlackLivesMatter movement.
I mentioned in an earlier post that part of the reason for this erasure has to do with the frustrating mistreatment that Asian Americans who support Peter Liang’s indictment have faced within our community: those of us who express this position must contend with being labelled as “race traitors” or worse.
Yet, those of us who support Peter Liang’s indictment are not seeking disproportionate or unfair treatment for an Asian American police officer compared to a White one. Rather, we seek a system that holds all police accountable for their actions, regardless of their race. Professor David Shih recently wrote on his blog:
There are many Asian Americans who not only agree with this position, but who see this as a critical battleground that will decide the place Asian Americans choose to inhabit in a more racially just America. Will we fight for a more equal future where no human life can be taken without consequence? Or, will we fight to defend a system that values authoritarian order over the lives of our Black brothers and sisters — the same system that thinks little of Yellow or Brown lives either?
This past week, CAAAV asked AAPI civil rights organizations to take a stand in support of indictment for Peter Liang, and for any police officer who images they can take the life of an unarmed, Black civilian without consequence. This past weekend, I joined over two dozen AAPI social justice groups as signatories to this open letter opposing those within our community who demand that criminal charges against Peter Liang be dropped. We find this demand to be both irrational and offensive; instead, we support justice for Akai Gurley and an end to police violence.
The letter reads in part:
If you — as an individual or as a member of an AAPI organization — would like to add your support to this letter, please visit this link and fill out the form and share this open letter with your entire network.
Did you like this content? Please consider becoming a patron of Reappropriate and get exclusive access to the brand new Reappropriate vlog!
You Might Also Like...
Since 2001, Reappropriate has been the web's foremost Asian American activism, identity, feminism, and pop culture blog!